The Fall
http://www.amazon.com/Fall-BD-Live-Blu-ray/dp/B001BPJJ82
What Is Your Favorite Blu-ray To Demo Video?


David has featured nearly 60 titles in Ultimate Demos, and he will continue to add to the list. But there are many more movies available on Blu-ray than he can possibly cover, so I'm asking for your help in identifying more demo-worthy discs.
This week, I'd like to know which 2D Blu-ray you think has the best video qualitiesdetail, color, black, shadow detail, etc.with which to demonstrate the capabilities of a display system. (Next week, I'll ask the same question about audio.) Simply select "Here it is" below and leave a comment with your favorite title(s) and which qualities of the video are particularly outstanding; you might even identify specific scenes to help the rest of us find the best moments.
Vote to see the results and leave a comment with your favorite title(s); thanks for your input!
- Login or register to post comments


"Your favorite blu-ray demo" is subjective and varies with the physiological and psychological conditions of each person. What one person may perceive as being toned-down in color may be another person's rainbow. I have many favorites. Criterion has been really doing some great restoration work with some of the classics. You must try Jacques Tati's "Playtime". Not counting the opening credits, the rest of the movie is very film-like, and that to me is one of the finest points for blu-ray demo material status; experiencing the cinema at home. Of course ideally a good front projection set-up is of the essence in a properly controlled and calibrated home theater.

Thank you for reminding me about that film! That is one of the most visual astounding and beautiful films I've ever seen and blu-ray showcases it perfectly. I also thought it rather touching, not to mention highly original in terms of story and, more importantly, story-telling. Another plus is that it seems to have finally dropped into the price range I like to see... another one for the collection!


The Star Trek reboot has been cited a few times so I list it simply to reiterate that it's a great go-to disc. How to Train Your Dragon has the kind of sharp transfer that we've come to expect from modern CG animated films but what I find unique and useful about it is how, in the scenes near the end of the film, it handles the myriad particle effects that can be seen during the climax. Those effects are particularly hard to fully resolve and must have been a headache during the mastering process. It's a very good test to see how well your display resolves fine picture detail.



I am really surprised no one has said this movie. The opening scene until they get into the fog is amazing. Water splashing, creaking of the ship, footsteps. Then when the other ship opens up on them all the creaking plus shattering wood etc. I always use this as a demo. House of flying daggers the bean scene is also great. Dark Knight when the plane sweeps down to pick him up from China, great show for the bass. I don't know why but I love Rambo (2008) when he opens up with with the 50 cal.
There are so many hard to nail just one or even a couple.


Correct. From LCD to plasma. A while back I heard you remark that efforts in LCD/LED development are focused, in part, on solving problems plasmas never had. My next to top model Panasonic plasma uses less power than my late 2008 LCD. It's sounds silly but, in my eyes, everything has changed for me after the transition.
I think we should hold onto terms like "footage" and "rolling" as long as we can when shooting digital cinema.


Scott - the fall is a great film
It's one of my top 5 Favorite films
Endearing characters with some of the best cinematography and art direction you'll find on film anywhere - you'll be surprised to learn how little CGI was used in the film
If you haven't seen it yet you should!

The Dark Knight with those IMAX shots look great. The blacks and shadow detail are also jaw dropping. The Ten Commandments for its 6K transfer and outstanding colors.
BTW, I went to the AXPONA show last week in Atlanta and enjoyed myself. It was fantastic. I was able to chat with former HT editor Shane Buettner and had a brief chat with Michael Fremer.

Star Trek is great eye candy and I prefer it to Avatar how ever great the transfer of Avatar is because Star Trek looks real not CG and the sound is incredible. for technicolor restoration you can't beat Wizard of Oz cause everyone has seen it for many years on crappy 480i NTSC which gives them something to compare to. Only wish more people would speak-out against all these streaming services including netflix which is the biggest problem we face. people see streaming and find it looking fine...rubbish! we all need to educate people on why blu-ray is the only way to watch a feature film streaming is great for talking head shows like your great show "home theater geeks", but should not be used for movies.



I'm currently looking for one or two demo BRDs because I'm 3 months post LCD-plasma transition which has really set the bar high for evaluating blacks and highlight/shadow detail. Lately, I've been using 2001 as there are very light and very dark scenes even though it's from 1960's film stock.
I predict many of us will eventually find our demo disks to be those photographed on Red cameras.
HTG and watching Robert Heron on Rev3 are the best AV shows.

http://www.criterion.com/films/632-black-narcissus
It wasn't until the blu-ray that I realized this may be the most beautiful technicolor film ever made. Glorious to behold!

I think my most go to demo for new visitors in my home theater is the opening 15 minutes or so of The Dark Knight. As said those Imax shots are amazing and the blacks are so inky that it really shows off the capability of my Pioneer Kuro. Also love to use Avatar as well. As of lately I have been using episodes of The Pacific on Bluray for demos. That series has some excellent cinamatography especially out in the field during war scenes and the audio is incredible! I also love to use Wall-E or Cars or any Pixar title for that matter. I really need to pick up a copy of Baraka as I would love to finally view this beautifull bluray.

Not hard to believe at all. I own all three seasons, and am consistently dazzled by them. Facial detail on men (women were usually shot in soft focus) can be very impressive. The bright primary colors on the uniforms and the sets are deep and rich in HD. The glittery rocks on the planet sets, and the glittery threads in alien costumes, are nifty to look at.
Best episodes in HD:
The Cage (and, by extension, The Menagerie)
Where No Man Has Gone Before
Journey to Babel
Amok Time
Spectre of the Gun
The Cloud Minders

Are we demonstrating the display's abilities, or the capabilities of the format?
----
If it's the display:
"Fight Club" is great for shadow detail. "Watchman" is also good for this. Dark movies with loads of detail, as long as the display is calibrated properly.
For eye-searing color, you can't beat "Speed Racer." It always impresses those in search of eye candy.
For naturalistic color and fine detail, something like "The Reader" or "Frost/Nixon" are great. The dust motes in the latter are particularly impressive.
----
If, however, you are demonstrating the capabilities of the format:
"The Ten Commandments" is an utterly magnificent argument for the benefits of the format for mid-century widescreen film formats. Detail is wondrous, and color is superb.
"2001: A Space Odyssey" for similar reasons. The detail level on knobs and dials is great, and the contrast on space shots and moon scenes is superb.
For new movies that demonstrate the format well, I'd choose these:
JJ Abrams' "Star Trek," for all its egregious story logic problems, is one heck of a tech demo. The glittering detritus of space battles is very impressive.
"The Dark Knight" is of course great for its IMAX footage. Very punchy and detailed scenes.
-----
OK, so now instead of wussing out and picking a dozen, I'll narrow it down to one pick apiece (display and format).
For the display, I'd go with "Watchmen." It has the widest range of dark to light, fine detail to splashy color, to really show you what a display can do.
For the format, I'd go with "Ten Commandments. Every time I pop it in, I get sucked in and watch the whole thing, or at least all of one disc. It's that engrossing a visual experience, and is just so impressive given its age.
-----
Now, I looked again at the initial post, and it implied that impressing relatives is a factor. In which case TDK or Speed Racer are probably your best bets.



Another fave is The Dark Knight; the opening shots of the city skyline exhibit exquisite detail, and there are plenty of dark scenes that test a display's capability to reproduce shadow detail.
| Displays Speakers | HT Systems Sources Electronics | Other Gear Software AV Interiors |
Top Picks
|
Community Show Reports |
Blogs
|
Shop Resources Subscriptions |



