Behind the Curtain

Who doesn't love The Wizard of Oz? No one I know. Rated as one of the best films ever made, this timeless classic has been released on various home-video formats no less than 16 times since 1980. Now, 70 years after its theatrical debut, Oz is getting its first high-def treatment on Blu-ray for the 17th iteration. I was fortunate to be invited to a press event celebrating this milestone at Warner Brothers' Burbank studio, and I learned a lot about what went into making this ultimate version.

Oz is one of the most protected films of all time—it seems the producers knew they had something special, so they took great care to ensure its survival. In addition to the original nitrate camera negative, they made one set of "safety separations" (red, green, and blue elements). Release prints were made by Technicolor from "printing matrices," which were the intermediate elements between the original camera negative and the final release print. Then, in 1993, a new "interpositive" was made from the original camera negative as an archival element from which subsequent home-video releases were derived.

Over the years, various restorations have been performed, often not from the original elements. For example, the 1989 50th Anniversary edition used a Technicolor print from CBS as the source. The color was correct in that print, but it was very soft.

The last DVD version was produced in 2004 using Warner's Ultra-Resolution process, in which the original camera negative was scanned at 4K, and the RGB elements were aligned in a computer by dividing the image into a 4x4 grid. But even 4K wasn't good enough for the Blu-ray release, so Warner rescanned the original camera negative at 8K. And since 2004, the Ultra-Resolution software has been improved so much that the RGB alignment can now be performed pixel by pixel, and the color-correction function is much better as well.

But how did the Warner engineers know what the colors were supposed to look like? No one from the original crew is still around, and even if they were, memories fade after 70 years. Fortunately, an original 1939 "answer print"—a print made so the director could check the color—was found in the archives of the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences at UCLA, which Warner used as a reference.

The result of all these technical machinations is stunning, as we saw in several clips played on a 50-inch Panasonic professional plasma and Christie 2K projector. According to a Warner rep, the biggest improvement over the previous DVD release is in the fine detail—you can see hairs in the witch's mole and blemishes on young Judy Garland's chin and forehead. The color is much better as well, including subtle gradations in the witch's green makeup and Dorothy's skin tones.

Also, the image is more dimensional, and the various visual elements are more integrated into an organic whole. For example, the poppies and City of Oz scrim were obviously fake in the previous release, but they look much more natural here.

Film buffs will be happy to learn that Warner didn't artificially reduce film grain as it did in the 2005 release. In fact, scanning at 8K revealed that what was thought to be grain was actually noise and scaling artifacts induced at lower resolutions.

The Wizard of Oz Blu-ray is scheduled to be released on September 29, and I can't wait to watch it in my home theater. Maybe I'll invite some of the Munchkins over—I see one of the original actors shopping at my local Von's every once in a while. I wonder if that store carries giant lollipops?

Share | |
Comments
Seth G.'s picture

Any information on the color bit depth seeing as how this was techinicolor this would be a film that would benefit from deep color and beyond. I remember reading a bit from criterion a while back that one of the things that excited them about blu ray was the support for 10 and 12 bit color depth, which would allow them for the first time to present technicolor films with the color gamut originally portrayed in the film, but as you pointed out after 70 years memory does fade as to what was the actual colors may have been, and having a color reference as this film did may not be the case for others.

Infominister's picture

Is it still 1:33 aspect ratio, or has it somehow been "widened" to 1:78 for widescreen TV purposes?

David Vaughn's picture

To our loyal readers, I will also be doing a review of this title and an Ultimate Demo of specific scenes that highlight the best aspects of the new transfer. Look for these next week! Best, David Vaughn

Scott Wilkinson's picture

Infominister, according to Warner, the aspect ratio is actually 1.37:1, the original aspect ratio of the movie. It was not stretched or cropped for widescreen TVs. Seth, my contact at Warner does not know the bit depth that was used on the Blu-ray; I'm still trying to find someone who knows for sure. I strongly suspect it's 8 bits, just like all other Blu-rays to date. BTW, bit depth has nothing to do with color gamut; instead, it determines the number of gradations in brightness for each color.

ender21's picture

.... though the 8k scan itself was very likely 10-bit DPX.

Scott Wilkinson's picture

Could very well be, Ender; they used a Northlight scanner. But I'm fairly confident that the Blu-ray is 8-bit.

Ender21's picture

Oh I agree with that 100%. I just inferred from one of the OP's statements that he was interested in knowing what the source bit depth was for the scans, not just the master hdcam-sr.

Walter Bartner's picture

Has Warner considered releasing a basic single blu-ray disc along with extras? I am not interested in buying that elaborate box set. A single blu-ray would make me more than happy. I live in a New York apartment and space has always been a problem.

Scott Wilkinson's picture

Walter, Warner has, in fact, done just what you are asking for in two retailer-specific editions. Target has a 3-disc version without the swag for $35, and Walmart has a single-disc version (basically, Disc 1 from the Ultimate Collector's Edition) for $20. The Target edition includes all the bonus content (except a digital copy), while the Walmart version doesn't provide much beyond the movie itself.

Site Map / Direct Links