Alón by Acarian Napoleon Surround Speaker System Page 2
Back in the spring of 2001 I reviewed a 5.1-channel satellite-subwoofer system from Edge Audio—now Aperion Audio—sold only via the Internet. The package consisted of five small 2-way satellites plus a powered subwoofer featuring a front-ported, front-firing long-throw 12-inch driver. For a grand total of $1399, the system offered surprisingly fine performance and reasonably high build quality, along with some unusual features, including the patented DiAural crossover technology, which is said to have certain advantages over more standard crossover designs. The Edge system had many laudable qualities, but I found the overall sound to be "stuffy and congested," and lacking in perceived high-frequency extension. You can't have everything for $1399.
I was interested to hear what $2995 would buy today, compared to what I remembered of the sound of the then $1399 Aperion/Edge system. The Aperion was no longer on hand, but I did play some of the same music tracks on the Alón package that I had used to evaluate the Aperion system, including: James Taylor's Live at the Beacon Theater (Columbia Music Video CVD 50171); Jonathan Demme's superb Talking Heads concert, Stop Making Sense (Palm Video PalmDVD 3013-2) and Sessions at West 54th Street (Columbia Music Video CVD 50163).
Whether because of the DiAural crossover or something else, my sonic recollection was that the Aperion/Edge system produced a larger, more spacious picture overall; otherwise, the Napoleon system was the hands-down winner—which, at twice the price, it should be. The Thunderbolt's fast, articulate bottom end delivered stunning results with Suzanne Vega's "Caramel," with super-tight bass attack and properly sized, pleasing heft. Whereas the Aperion/Edge system had sounded closed-in, congested, and lacking in air and transparency, the Napoleons sounded open, transparent, and easy on the ears. The transients of acoustic guitar strums were cleanly rendered, and the balance between the attack and the resonance of the instrument's wooden body produced a believable guitar sound free of boxiness, hollowness, or bloat.
Switching to films, as California's new governor motorcycled through the storm drains of Sherman Oaks in Terminator 2, chased by Gray Davis—er, I mean the T1000 sent to destroy him—his shotgun blasts had plenty of impact; and in terms of both weight and articulation, the explosion of the gasoline tanker truck was something a much bigger system would have been proud to reproduce. (Can an explosion be articulate?)
But even with the system dialed-in perfectly, there was still a loss of lower-midbass bloom and richness with the Napoleon-Thunderbolt system that left the entire sonic picture a bit lightweight. Such a lack of midbass richness often translates into center-channel dialog that's slightly thin and lacking in ultimate believability—but thanks to the clarity, articulation, and freedom from bloat and overhang of both the Thunderbolt and the Alón satellites, male and female voices were pleasing and intelligible if not fully formed. It's always easier to ignore an omission than to try to cut your way through a tacked-on coloration such as chestiness or muddiness. The Alóns' off-axis response seemed smooth and free of major dips at normal distances (but leave it to TJN's measurements to show some major troughs!).
Five small, identical satellites will almost always create a large acoustic bubble, and the Alón Napoleon system was no exception. Visitors—especially experienced audio/videophiles—were as uniformly impressed by the system's wide-open tonal balance and crisp clarity as they were by the scale and integrity of the 5.1-channel presentation; but when dialog was emanating from the center channel, it sounded small.
Toward the end of the two months I spent with the Napoleon system, Linn's Unidisk universal disc player arrived and I was assigned to review a stack of multichannel DVD-Audio and SACD discs. Because Carl Marchisotto's background is in designing speakers for 2-channel music reproduction, it should come as no surprise that this little system performed remarkably well at this task. Still, I wasn't surprised when I set up an Aerial surround system costing well over $30,000 and heard an enormous improvement.
This is a fine-sounding small system with a top-shelf subwoofer, but it can't perform miracles of timbral richness, tonal neutrality, dynamic slam, spaciousness, or resolution of low-level detail, so don't expect them. For instance, the 5.1-channel mix of the Beach Boys' Pet Sounds (Capitol 72434-77937-9-0) produces an enormous, cavernous spatial picture, with great weight. The Napoleon system created a fine musical performance, especially rhythmically, but couldn't come close to delivering the weight, space, or delirious richness I got from the Aerial system. It shouldn't be expected to.
The petite Alón Napoleon system offers a combination of pluses and minuses anyone constrained by space should consider. As in the $1399 Aperion system to which I compared it in this review, the star of the Alón system is its subwoofer, available separately for $1695. The Thunderbolt sub is an exceptional performer regardless of price, and it's worth considering under any circumstances, but especially if your home theater has serious space limitations and doubles as your music system. Is the Thunderbolt worth three times the cost of the sub supplied with the Aperion/Edge system? I don't know about the sub Aperion currently offers, but compared with the one I reviewed, absolutely. The Thunderbolt is built to a higher level of quality and goes way further down, while managing far greater musical suppleness and sophistication.
The question is, how much are you willing to spend for five tiny, not particularly stylish satellites? While I could list a number of other small 2-way satellites (such as the NHT SB-2 at $400/pair, the PSB Alpha B at $249/pair, or the Paradigm Atom at $189/pair) that would seem to offer more speaker and/or more style for the same money or a few dollars more than the little Napoleons, there's no way I can guarantee better performance without actually hearing those combinations.
Perhaps part of the secret of the Alón system's success is that its designer considered the speed and detail of his Thunderbolt subwoofer when designing the Napoleons. The fact that the satellites' bass performance is undernourished but articulate is perhaps the key to their noteworthy integration with the Thunderbolt, and to the overall long-term listening satisfaction I got from this system.
In the world of high-end audio from which this system springs, value is measured as much, if not more, by subjective performance as by the total cost of the parts used. Is the Alón Napoleon system worth twice as much as the Aperion/Edge system I reviewed a few years ago? Considering the Napoleons' airy, open, uncongested top end, the superbly nimble, deep, and musical bottom end of the sub, and the overall easy listenability of the system as a whole, I'd have to say yes. Whether it's worth spending more than a few thousand dollars on any mini-satellite-subwoofer system is another question. You'll have to answer that one for yourself.